Everton V West Bromwich Albion

Knight of Thorgothshire wrote:

Yankthattoffee wrote:

Knight of Thorgothshire wrote:Not sure that Jags would have let that happen, Williams and Holgate not on the same wave length at all on that goal.

was it offside? MOTD didn't show it. (not unusual)

Jags is much more of a leader, organizing the defence, something which Holgate is learning and Williams apparently can't do since we tend to concede when he's playing.

Yes, I given the options I would have Jags in defence as first choice.  Holgate is at the stage of being horrendous one week and decent the next.  John Stones was a bit like that wasn't he?

Yankthattoffee wrote:

Knight of Thorgothshire wrote:

hairy cataract wrote:

Knight of Thorgothshire wrote:

Yankthattoffee wrote:

Knight of Thorgothshire wrote:Not sure that Jags would have let that happen, Williams and Holgate not on the same wave length at all on that goal.

was it offside? MOTD didn't show it. (not unusual)

Jags is much more of a leader, organizing the defence, something which Holgate is learning and Williams apparently can't do since we tend to concede when he's playing.

Yes, I given the options I would have Jags in defence as first choice.  Holgate is at the stage of being horrendous one week and decent the next.  John Stones was a bit like that wasn't he?

He was, and that's why I think it's really important that Holgate gets to play next to Jags. He should learn a lot from Jags.

Jags is next to useless in the air.
Hence his great performance against the Shyte, who have little aerial threat, and the need for Williams when playing a team with air-power.
Having said that, Williams is a liability.
What Walcott made of all that is probably not what we want to hear, but I can't see how we use his pace, if we can't get decent service to him. Maybe Coleman will be a good foil, but we'll have to wait and see.
Vlasic looks lost. Siggy too slow, Bolasie too much like a show horse. Schnide looks confused, Tosun looks like another Beattie, Lil' Tom has gone missing, so what's not to love?

Sam said what I was thinking after the match - the team are going to have to learn where Walcott wants the ball. You could see Theo getting frustrated in the match but to be fair, he's only had one training session with us.  We've got ten days now to work on what Walcott wants.  We need to build everything around him in attack because he's so much better than the rest of the team.  Hopefully we'll now see a different Siggi - one of his strengths is the quick through ball and he's finally got someone to play it to.  I reckon Niasse will be coming off the bench quite a lot in the next few weeks, because he's the only natural goalscorer we have.  Pity he's such a shit footballer though.

Yankthattoffee wrote:

hairy cataract wrote:

Yankthattoffee wrote:

Knight of Thorgothshire wrote:

hairy cataract wrote:

Knight of Thorgothshire wrote:

Yankthattoffee wrote:

Knight of Thorgothshire wrote:Not sure that Jags would have let that happen, Williams and Holgate not on the same wave length at all on that goal.

was it offside? MOTD didn't show it. (not unusual)

Jags is much more of a leader, organizing the defence, something which Holgate is learning and Williams apparently can't do since we tend to concede when he's playing.

Yes, I given the options I would have Jags in defence as first choice.  Holgate is at the stage of being horrendous one week and decent the next.  John Stones was a bit like that wasn't he?

He was, and that's why I think it's really important that Holgate gets to play next to Jags. He should learn a lot from Jags.

Jags is next to useless in the air.
Hence his great performance against the Shyte, who have little aerial threat, and the need for Williams when playing a team with air-power.
Having said that, Williams is a liability.
What Walcott made of all that is probably not what we want to hear, but I can't see how we use his pace, if we can't get decent service to him. Maybe Coleman will be a good foil, but we'll have to wait and see.
Vlasic looks lost. Siggy too slow, Bolasie too much like a show horse. Schnide looks confused, Tosun looks like another Beattie, Lil' Tom has gone missing, so what's not to love?

Sam said what I was thinking after the match - the team are going to have to learn where Walcott wants the ball. You could see Theo getting frustrated in the match but to be fair, he's only had one training session with us.  We've got ten days now to work on what Walcott wants.  We need to build everything around him in attack because he's so much better than the rest of the team.  Hopefully we'll now see a different Siggi - one of his strengths is the quick through ball and he's finally got someone to play it to.  I reckon Niasse will be coming off the bench quite a lot in the next few weeks, because he's the only natural goalscorer we have.  Pity he's such a shit footballer though.

With all that in mind, I'm surprized he didn't have Theo on the bench.
As for Niasse, he could well be our best striker right now.
It's interesting to see that we were talking about selling him 2 weeks ago, but as soon as Tosun plays 2 games, we seeme to be keeping him now.
I'll go down the route of Cloughie and Shankly who said they could tell if a player was any good from the way he ran.
With that in mind, Tosun has a very unathletic gait, and the WBA CBs bullied him all afternoon. I was expecting someone with a bit more meat on him, cause Rondon showed everyone how it's done.

It's weird - we don't seem to buy athletic players these days.  Spurs are choc full of them and, as you say, Rondon was outstanding against us and he's got a lot of muscle on him.  I reckon DCL could do with filling out a bit, then he might be our Harry Kane.  Would help if he knew where the goal was of course.  I still think Tosun will come good.  His first touch looks handy, but he's had no service so far (welcome to Everton).  Time till tell if he's the new Sandro/Beattie or not.